A discussion forum for history enthusiasts everywhere
 
HomeHome  Recent ActivityRecent Activity  Latest imagesLatest images  RegisterRegister  Log inLog in  SearchSearch  

Share | 
 

 How did plaid kilts become feminine clothing?

View previous topic View next topic Go down 
AuthorMessage
Gduj15662
Quaestor
Gduj15662

Posts : 20
Join date : 2024-02-08

How did plaid kilts become feminine clothing? Empty
PostSubject: How did plaid kilts become feminine clothing?   How did plaid kilts become feminine clothing? EmptySat 02 Mar 2024, 05:17

Why did people adopt the plaid skirt with folded knife pleats for females even though it was invented and originally worn by Scottish males? Which culture and country did these skirts come from and who invented these skirts?
Or are the Celtic males who wore them homosexual? This is not meant to be an offensive racist question. I am just curious. I heard some people say that the Celtic males who wore those plaid kilted skirts were actually female in personality. Is this true?
I mean now in the West and in the whole world, the kilted plaid skirt is seen and used by many as a very feminine clothing such as in Western highschools. How did this happen? How did a piece of clothing originally worn by Celtic males come to be used and seen as a very feminine clothing? 

Why did those Celtic skirts get adopted as feminine clothing? What was the psychology behind this? And how can we stop pleated kilted plaid skirts from being used, seen, and portrayed as feminine clothing in highschools and in all places and give it the proper respect it deserves which is to not culturally appropriate those skirts. We can prevent cultural appropriation of those skirts by letting only Scottish males wear them.

By the way, I find it funny that Celtic males get butthurt when people call tartan kilts as skirts despite the fact that they look and function the same as any other types of skirts.

Whose idea was it to make plaid kilted skirts as feminine clothing? Who are the people who started to turn those skirts into clothings used by females? Who are the people responsible for this?
Back to top Go down
Meles meles
Censura
Meles meles

Posts : 5122
Join date : 2011-12-30
Location : Pyrénées-Orientales, France

How did plaid kilts become feminine clothing? Empty
PostSubject: Re: How did plaid kilts become feminine clothing?   How did plaid kilts become feminine clothing? EmptySat 02 Mar 2024, 15:25

I don't know. However just be aware that the modern 'skirt-like' Scottish kilt really only dates from the eighteenth century. What was essentially the same as the modern kilt was known as the small kilt or walking kilt and this was probably invented by Thomas Rawlinson, an English Quaker from Lancashire in the 1720s. This was when water-powered Lancashire weaving mills were starting to greatly increase the amount of woolen cloth available and also when, following the 1707 Act of Union between England and Scotland, and with military action being taken against the rebellious Scottish Jacobites, the remote highlands of Scotland were starting to come under more control and be more accessible to outsiders. Thomas Rawlinson likely just saw these developments as giving him an opportunity to sell more cloth in Scotland. Prior to that the usual costume in the Scottish highlands was the belted plaid or great kilt (feileadh mòr) which was a full-length garment made of a large rectangle of cloth (made from two loom-widths sewn together, so about 60 inches wide, and up to 7 yards in length), whose upper half could be worn as a cloak draped over the shoulder or brought up over the head as a hood, with only the lower part belted around the waist to form a skirt around the legs.

The full great kilt or plaid was only usually worn by the highland clans and even then the earliest references to it are only from the sixteenth century. My Scottish ancestors were lowland Scots from Lothian and Fife, and the men most likely wore exactly the same as the majority of western Europeans, that is in medieval and renaissance times a pair of tight-fitting hose (tights/leggings) held up with points (laces) attached to a doublet (a close-fitting under jacket), then later on they would have worn breeches with stockings, and finally trousers or perhaps trews, which were a uniquely Scottish style of close-fitting trouser. As clothing in the impoverished, rainy and boggy highlands, the full plaid was probably very practical as it left the lower legs bare and so didn't get sodden with water and mud, while the upper part functioned as a cloak and hood against the weather. The whole garment could also readily double as a combined sleeping blanket and groundsheet when out on the moors tending to the huge herds of cattle that were the mainstay of the highland economy.


Last edited by Meles meles on Sun 03 Mar 2024, 16:28; edited 3 times in total (Reason for editing : Thomas Rawlinson only probably invented the small kilt as it's origin is disputed by some)
Back to top Go down
Vizzer
Censura
Vizzer

Posts : 1853
Join date : 2012-05-12

How did plaid kilts become feminine clothing? Empty
PostSubject: Re: How did plaid kilts become feminine clothing?   How did plaid kilts become feminine clothing? EmptySun 03 Mar 2024, 14:14

There is a fondly held belief among some in the British military that during the First World War the Germans referred to the Highland regiments as ‘devils in skirts’ or ‘ladies from hell’. There is, however, little or no evidence for this. Indeed, the fashion for women in the decades leading up to and during the First World War was not for skirts at all but for full-length dresses. This would put a further question mark over the origin of those nicknames. 

Very few women or girls before the First World War would have worn kilts. That said - this picture from the 19th Century shows a lady in a plaid dress with her 2 daughters in tartan skirts and her son in a kilt.  

How did plaid kilts become feminine clothing? Ki05

(The Duchess of Strathearn with her children, 1890s)

After the First World War as the length of women’s skirts shortened there were some examples of women and girls wearing tartan skirts in the 1920s although it was still very rare. By the 1930s it had become slightly more prevalent, notably with the British royal children Elizabeth and Margaret being photographed in tartan skirts during that decade. 

In the 1940s Ginger Rogers wore a kilt during the number My One and Only Highland Fling alongside the equally kilted Fred Astaire in the 1949 musical The Barkleys of Broadway. 2 years later in 1951, the British royals were again in the limelight, when Queen Elizabeth and her daughters Elizabeth and Margaret (this time as adults) all wore kilts while out for a walk in Balmoral on the occasion of Margaret’s 21st birthday. During the rest of the 1950s the wearing of plaid skirts became increasingly popular among women, particularly in North America. By the end of that decade and into the early 1960s plaid skirts were already being incorporated as uniform in many schools. With the advent of the miniskirt in the 1960s, tartan miniskirts became popular. 1968 would see, among others, the likes of Brigitte Bardot and Scotland’s very own Lulu sporting plaid minis. 
  
In 1972, when Gordonstoun School in Morayshire became one of the first private schools in Britain to go co-educational, the uniform for the new intake of girls was a tartan skirt. The school’s public image was very high-profile at the time as it was where the then Prince Charles had been educated and where his younger brothers would also attend. Charles, however, is said to have disliked his time there referring to it as ‘Colditz with kilts’. Since then, the plaid skirt has become popular as school uniform for girls around the world ranging from North America to Africa to East Asia. As far as I’m aware I don’t think that Scotsmen are that bothered about cultural appropriation because, as Meles has pointed out regarding the 18th Century historical invention, there is also a big difference between a plaid skirt and a tartan kilt.
Back to top Go down
Meles meles
Censura
Meles meles

Posts : 5122
Join date : 2011-12-30
Location : Pyrénées-Orientales, France

How did plaid kilts become feminine clothing? Empty
PostSubject: Re: How did plaid kilts become feminine clothing?   How did plaid kilts become feminine clothing? EmptyFri 08 Mar 2024, 08:50

In the 17th and early 18th centuries, when many male highlanders still routinely wore the great plaid, their womenfolk wore something similar, called the earasaid or arisaid. This again was a large rectangular piece of cloth that could be pleated and fixed around the waist with a belt, with the spare material wrapped around the shoulders, fixed with a pin or broach at the front or on one shoulder and with enough surplus material to form a hood that could be pulled up in bad weather. The arisaid was not in itself used as a dress or kilt-like skirt but was worn over a conventional full-length sleeved dress (often with additional petticoats under the dress if the wearer could afford them) and so it functioned as a warm top covering or over-mantle that could also be drawn up to cover the head or used to wrap up babies close to the mother's body. The arisaid was often not tartan but was dyed a plain colour, maybe with a coloured border or simple stripes.

How did plaid kilts become feminine clothing? Kilt-33   How did plaid kilts become feminine clothing? Kilt-11  How did plaid kilts become feminine clothing? Kilt-44

The first drawing is from 1754, so shortly after the wearing of highland dress was banned by the Dress Act of 1746 although this didn't apply to women and as her man is a soldier in British highland regiment his particular plaid is also exempt as it's part of an officially-recognised regimental uniform. The other two are from 1845 when all things Scottish were starting to enjoy a revival, but are reconstructions based on written descriptions of about 150 years earlier. I think strictly the lass on the right isn't wearing a full arisaid but rather a simpler plaid shawl known as a tonnag.

The point to note is that they are all wearing conventional (for the time) long skirts under their over-mantel, and that again none of these women are actually wearing kilts.
Back to top Go down
Sponsored content




How did plaid kilts become feminine clothing? Empty
PostSubject: Re: How did plaid kilts become feminine clothing?   How did plaid kilts become feminine clothing? Empty

Back to top Go down
 

How did plaid kilts become feminine clothing?

View previous topic View next topic Back to top 
Page 1 of 1

 Similar topics

-
» Feminine occupational terms

Permissions in this forum:You cannot reply to topics in this forum
Res Historica History Forum :: The history of people ... :: Customs, traditions, etiquette and ethics-